
The scene was Ralph's Coffee and Tea House in Sidney, BC. Four of us were seated around the table, including Ralph, his Ferrari-owning friend Don, a car guy whose name I've forgotten, and me. The conversation wandered to Vancouver and mass transit, wherein I suggested that the city had the best public transportation system in North America. My table-mates were shocked. They simply couldn't imagine that our west coast system could compete with New York, San Francisco, or even Toronto.
I argued differently, pointing out that the SkyTrain is everything overhead transport should be. That the new Canada Line subway is an advanced technology connecting downtown with the airport and points between. That the futuristic SeaBus joins the mainland with North Vancouver in 12-minute sailings every quarter hour. And that even though surface transport depends on traditional buses, many of those vehicles are new-generation electric trolley buses. Although tiny by comparison, I was pleased to add the water taxis scooting across False Creek to Granville Island like June Bugs on a hot summer night.
For those who've never visited this beautiful city a few words of explanation are in order. The SkyTrain is an overhead rail system that bears no resemblance to the overheads in New York or Chicago. The tramway is light in appearance and elegant, each of the contemporary stations unique in design. Tickets are purchased from automatic machines and possession of same is all that's needed. Although attendants now patrol the cars to make random checks of ticket holders, it's an honour system. The cars have large windows offering excellent views of the city. And there are no drivers or conductors. Operation is entirely computer-controlled. There has not been an accident since the SkyTrain's launch in 1986. Think "horizontal elevators."
SeaBuses are 125-seat catamarans that join downtown to the city's north shore quickly and comfortably. Tourists ride them just for the panoramic views of mountains and harbour. The same honour system as on the SkyTrain applies. More than just ferries, they include doors that open automatically to match doors on the enclosed docks, making entry and exit quick and easy.
The Canada Line is Vancouver's first subway, which surprised me on my initial ride for I'd expected something similar to the SkyTrain. Nevertheless it's the best underground rail line I've ever experienced, and I've been on more than a few. The downtown terminus meets both the SkyTrain and SeaBus, as well as the helicopter commuter line between Vancouver and BC's capitol city of Victoria. At the opposite end is Vancouver International Airport, with intermediate neighbourhood stops. It is airy, spacious, quiet and... drivers are not required.
As for those new trolley buses they, too, surprised me on first meeting. I was under the impression that electric trolley buses were a thing of the past (unfortunately, for they use no fossil fuel) until I saw Vancouver's fleet of handsome, powerful units. I'm not a big fan of buses but until we can have affordable fuel cells for street transit the trolley bus (like hybrids) is a decent compromise. By way of comparison, I just spent two weeks in Toronto, my hometown, where I frequently rode the subway, streetcars, and buses. Toronto has always boasted of its transit system but its rock-hard seats, overcrowded subways, and slow-moving streetcars can't begin to compare with Vancouver.
By the time I'd finished boasting of the advantages of Vancouver's transit system my tablemates had stopped laughing and begrudgingly agreed with me. In reality it may not be the world's best but it is certainly world class. And that's something planners everywhere should keep in mind as we move to a more integrated system of automobile freedom and transit mobility.